Fans have been buzzing about this during the hiatus, and I even made a video speculating that Robin could be the one who stabbed Gary. Personally, I still think it was a woman, but let’s consider what Crystal mentioned during her appearance on The Sherri Shepherd Show with Pam and KJ. She hinted that the identity of Gary’s attacker would be a complete surprise—a shocking twist that left even her in disbelief upon reading the script.
I believe it could be a character we haven’t seen in a while, like Jasmine or Robin. After all, the criminal often returns to the scene of the crime. Suddenly, we have Robin popping back into the picture, representing Andy. In the promo for next week, he says, “You’ve been through a lot,” referencing the stabbing, the interrogation, and possibly losing the love of your life.
Robin’s words and Andy’s reaction raise a question: Is Robin here out of the goodness of his heart to help Andy, or does he have an ulterior motive? With Gary out of the way, could Robin be thinking, “I stabbed that SOB Gary, and now I can help Andy”?
This scenario fits a crime of passion perfectly. Given Robin’s complicated history with Andy and the drama surrounding the Jordan situation, it’s a compelling theory. Yet, I still don’t believe Robin is the one who did it. If a man was responsible, I would expect some kind of scuffle. Gary likely let his guard down, but if Robin showed up unexpectedly, he would probably gloat, saying something like, “How’s life since you lost the law firm?”
Imagine Robin taunting Gary about Andy while suddenly stabbing him out of frustration. It’s a possibility, but I lean towards believing a woman was involved.
So, the big questions remain: Is Robin’s return merely a coincidence? Did he show up because he saw the news reports and wanted to help Andy, or has he been in town all along? And how did he know about the wedding venue?
Let’s discuss this in the comments! Don’t forget to like and subscribe, and I’ll catch you in the next video!
